Menu

CNET.com’s Animated Story Teaser

by Jared Spool

On the SIGIA-L discussion list, there’s been a discussion about the lateral links NYTimes.com is using.

In this discussion, the ever present Ziya Oz asked me:

Are you happier with the C|Net “semi-opaque sectional navigation” example I gave?

What Ziya is referring to is the Animated Story Teaser (my term), a lateral navigation design element that News.com is using to encourage readers to explore other articles on the site.

The Animated Story Teaser appears in the middle of a story:

Click to see the animated story teaser in a news.com article.
Click to see the animated story teaser in a news.com article

If you go to a news story (like this one), you can see the teaser in the middle of the page. It scrolls through several different stories, one after the other.

Teaser Sequence #1 Teaser Sequence #2 Teaser Sequence #3

If you move the mouse over the teaser element, the animation stops and two scroll controls appear in the lower right of the element:

Two scroll controls appear in the lower right when you move the mouse over the element

I think the concept is interesting.

The text is better than “10 of 14”, certainly. Because they are headlines, they run the risk that a lot of news sites run — the text is less informative and more “catchy”, thereby not communicating as much scent as they could. I wonder if these links communicate the best trigger words for their content.

The images, for the most part, don’t seem to communicate anything about what the story is about, so they feel ornamental to me. (Ornamental is one type of graphic. Two other types are Navigational — an image that communicates scent — and Content — an image that communicates information.) Our studies consistently show that ornamental graphics don’t add any real value (either for performance measures or subjective ratings), but do increase development time. Could you get the same value from the links with just a text-based presentation?

The fact that the reader needs to use the little scrolling controls to see the other articles is problematic. I actually never noticed this element before until Ziya pointed it out (and I probably visit the site 3-4 times per week). Our studies show that, on a site like this, most users keep their mouse on the scroll bar (or, when using a scroll wheel, keep the mouse still) until *after* they’ve decided what they are going to click on. I wonder if this presentation performs better than “The Pulse” presentation of links in the right column.

I’m also intrigued that the image is placed in the middle of the article, instead of at the end. If the reader is not done reading, will they be distracted by the article? Would it work better for most users if it was placed *after* the text? The question I have is where is the best placement for this, from a seducible moment perspective.

So, to summarize my answer to Ziya’s question:

Pros:

  • More useful text
  • potentially useful graphics

Cons:

  • Graphics could be a lot of work
  • not necessarily placed in layout well
  • must use mouse to see links
  • trigger words may still be missing