The Question that Won’t Die: Optimal Screen Resolution?
I recently got this email from a web designer at a state government agency:
Do you recommend that government sites be designed so that they scale depending on the user’s browser/screen resolution or be a fixed width?
I have not found much at www.uie.com regarding this issue.
A FIXED WIDTH FOR 800 x 600:
Our current site is designed at a fixed width of 750 pixels. Studies show that users prefer shorter lengths of screen text, hence our text lines are no longer than 420 pixels wide.A SCALABLE WIDTH OF 800 x 600 to 1024 x 768:
We are considering changing to a “liquid” design and letting the user decide what width they would like the content displayed. This would not be a problem for “power” users, but I am concerned that some of our users (the elderly and low literacy users) – may not know that they can manipulate content width.Readability and comprehension of our content is more important than speed. What do you recommend?
I can’t tell you how many times I’ve gotten this question. For years and years and years. It just won’t die.
For better or worse, here was my answer:
The reason we don’t talk to much about this on our site is that it’s far more important to focus on having the right content on your site.
In other words, no company has ever gone bankrupt because they chose the wrong width screen. However, many of the dot com failures can be tied to having poor content on their site.
To ensure you have the right content and that it’s presented in the right way, you’ll need to spend a lot of time with your users. As a side-benefit of spending that time with your users, you’ll see how they react to the layout of your page. If your screen width is wrong, this will be very clear to you, almost immediately.
Therefore, my recommendation is that you focus on ensuring you have the right content and make sure you have allocated the resources to find out if your design decisions are working for your users. I promise you that screen width will quickly become an unimportant issue.
Good luck with your design.